2015 Ashes - Australia In England

Bell has credit in the bank. Don't know what's up with Lyth and Ballance. Wanna see a day 5 pitch on day 1 at Edgbaston. Two spinners. Dart them at the pads, and Australia are stuffed.

How can poms complain about KP, when Lyth, Ballance are in the team? How stupid are they?

Since the end of the World Cup Bell has averaged 20.92 in test cricket from his last 13 innings. That average includes the 143 he made in the first innings against West Indies at North Sound. Take that knock out and he has averaged 10.75 from his last 12 hits which includes five scores of 1 and two ducks. His last 53 innings (which goes back to the New Zealand series in New Zealand early in 2013), he has scored 1728 runs at 34.56.

I have to say the figures above are pretty ordinary, particularly his last three and a bit months of test cricket. Bell may have done a fair bit for English cricket and he may have some points in the bank but to average little over 20 (and then scale that back to under 11 after removing that century against the Windies) simply isn't good enough. At 33 and in poor form you would have to think he may get a tap on the shoulder if things don't improve rather quickly.

Not picking KP is England's fault and gifting games to Lyth and Ballance when there's at least one top class batsman not getting a game leaves them purely at fault. They have at least stuck to their guns though and not relented. They obviously have standards both attitude and behavioural wise that they will not be compromised on. I, like you agree that not picking him has left their team worse off however.
 
There will be some changes I think, very hard not to after what was a diabolical effort. 103 all out on a road is simply unacceptable.

Lyth is on borrowed time you'd think as is Bell. There was a lot of talk on espncricinfo about Alex Hales coming in to open with Cook, ala similiar to Rogers/Warner for Australia.

As far as I'm aware, Hales hasn't been scoring any runs in county cricket so probably not a good idea. I still don't get why James Taylor isn't in the side but he's not an opener. They could go back to Robson? They didn't give him much of a chance off memory..
 
Taylor just scored 291 and he averages 45 at first-class and 51 at list-a level. Use your heads England!

Bairstow has also been in fine form this season.
 
England make one change...Bairstow for Ballance.. Good call? Would have thought Lyth or Bell would/should have been dropped first..

As for James Taylor not making the squad after his 291. He may as well give up on his English career, he's obviously not liked by the toffee noses at the top. Ireland wouldn't say no if he came knocking. :p
 
England make one change...Bairstow for Ballance.. Good call? Would have thought Lyth or Bell would/should have been dropped first..

As for James Taylor not making the squad after his 291. He may as well give up on his English career, he's obviously not liked by the toffee noses at the top. Ireland wouldn't say no if he came knocking. :p
Does this include Andrew Strauss?
 
Yup! Him and Alistair Cook are good mates. Would have loved to see someone like Michael Vaughn or Geoff Boycott come in instead in order to shake-up the 'old boys' club..

Andrew Strauss certainly hasn't come across as anything but a nice bloke, and certainly not a "toffee nose", on the 2 or 3 occasions I've run into him strolling around the main drag of Buninyong.
 
Andrew Strauss certainly hasn't come across as anything but a nice bloke, and certainly not a "toffee nose", on the 2 or 3 occasions I've run into him strolling around the main drag of Buninyong.

Fair enough mate. If you have actually met him then you are one up on me. Sometimes we can get a bit carried away with our perceptions of people on tv I reckon.
 
I'd be going with S Marsh too (assuming Rogers is ruled out).

I wonder if the selectors would consider that Watson brings an extra bowling option vs the guarantee that S Marsh would make more runs!

Time will tell.
 
A lot of talk going around that Haddin has played his last test match after not keeping in the tour game against Derbyshire so far. What a lot of people don't know is that Haddin and Nevill play for the same state (New South Wales) and also the same club cricket side (Eastern Suburbs). Whenever Haddin and Nevill play in the same side together for NSW and Eastern Suburbs Haddin lets Nevill keep wicket. So, I'm not convinced that Nevill will keep his spot for the third test.

Chris Rogers is also suffering from an inner ear problem and remains in doubt for the third test. Shaun Marsh scored another century in the game against Derbyshire before retiring out to put more pressure on the selectors for the game.
 
Well the third test starts Wednesday. My prediction of 3-0 has gone but maybe 3-1 is still on the cards. I imagine Haddin will play but he must be on notice, also Watson must now be history after the performance of Marsh in the second test. Mitch didn't really have a great game but still had an impact way above anything Watson has done for a long time. We will see if England really play two spinners in Edgbaston. I think they would be foolish as we have a few good players of spin. The issue has always been the swinging ball and the POMS seem to have lost that in their attack. Shaun MArsh is the easy step in for Rogers but this must be getting toward his last chance also. He has had opportunity and even with those couple of hundreds has not lived up to his potential.
 
I'd be going with S Marsh too (assuming Rogers is ruled out).

I wonder if the selectors would consider that Watson brings an extra bowling option vs the guarantee that S Marsh would make more runs!

Time will tell.
The only way i could see that is if they wanted to play two spinners.
 
Well the third test starts Wednesday. My prediction of 3-0 has gone but maybe 3-1 is still on the cards. I imagine Haddin will play but he must be on notice, also Watson must now be history after the performance of Marsh in the second test. Mitch didn't really have a great game but still had an impact way above anything Watson has done for a long time. We will see if England really play two spinners in Edgbaston. I think they would be foolish as we have a few good players of spin. The issue has always been the swinging ball and the POMS seem to have lost that in their attack. Shaun MArsh is the easy step in for Rogers but this must be getting toward his last chance also. He has had opportunity and even with those couple of hundreds has not lived up to his potential.

England sort of have two spinners at the moment in Ali and Root but they're stop gap options in my opinion. They really need to look at playing a proper specialist spinner for at least one game. Rashid would be the obvious choice but they seem pretty reluctant to play him.
 
Back
Top