DVCA: Best senior 11?

[rusty81]

Originally Posted by bat11dontbowl

if i were picking the comp side i would go with this

Mark Minney (Eltham)
Jason Arnberger (Lower Plenty)
Wayne Glynn (Diamond Creek)
Justin Witcher (Lower Eltham)
Glen Turner (Research)
David Love (Plenty)
Scott Gibbs (Riverside)
Brett Glynn (Diamond creek)
Chris Salvatore (Lower Eltham)
Claudio Angelucci (Epping)
Paul Baker (Mernda)

prob get turner to keep he used to at north melbourne. Thats pretty much based on performences the last few yrs (bar arnberger but that guy has made alot a 1st class runs)

players i just couldnt fit in but could easly slide in there
Conlan Gunn
Terry Keays
Leigh McTaggart
Elliot Smaele
Paul Hubber
Shane Waddingham (even though he did play e grade 2 yrs ago and tear my club apart in a grand final)

The reason why you didnt even consider Travis hand(monty) and Brent Zerafa (lower plenty)

[bat11dontbowl]

Originally Posted by rusty81

The reason why you didnt even consider Travis hand(monty) and Brent Zerafa (lower plenty)

i basicly picked a barclay shield side, i wouldnt mind seeing a barclay v money game i reckon it would be alot closer than ppl think.

yeah zerafa is another one i just couldnt fit in there, i know he played in the comp side last yr and i know he scores plenty of runs.
But i had to fit a keeper in there and i thought well turns can do it, lovey took plenty to 4 prems in a row would be a great captain skips prob the best bat atm yarra has had 10 - 15 years of dominating same with witcher. its actually bloody hard to pick. a 2nd side would be just as competative

Poyser
Connelly
Malone
Zerafa
Gunn
Smale
Waddingham
Keays
McTaggart
Adams
P.Hurst

[rusty81]

Originally Posted by bat11dontbowl

i basicly picked a barclay shield side, i wouldnt mind seeing a barclay v money game i reckon it would be alot closer than ppl think.

yeah zerafa is another one i just couldnt fit in there, i know he played in the comp side last yr and i know he scores plenty of runs.
But i had to fit a keeper in there and i thought well turns can do it, lovey took plenty to 4 prems in a row would be a great captain skips prob the best bat atm yarra has had 10 - 15 years of dominating same with witcher. its actually bloody hard to pick. a 2nd side would be just as competative

Poyser
Connelly
Malone
Zerafa
Gunn
Smale
Waddingham
Keays
McTaggart
Adams
P.Hurst

ok fair enough

[fmr_13]

for the reputation surrounding the bloke, this rosbrook from plenty hasnt seemed to make a big impact.
would he make the comp side to play the HDCA/JIKA games ?

[The430king]

Originally Posted by fmr_13

for the reputation surrounding the bloke, this rosbrook from plenty hasnt seemed to make a big impact.
would he make the comp side to play the HDCA/JIKA games ?

Has played about roughly 5 years of district cricket. Formerly a Plenty a junior. For me a walk up start.

[all day!]

Originally Posted by The430king

Has played about roughly 5 years of district cricket. Formerly a Plenty a junior. For me a walk up start.

Doesnt rosbrook bowl gas?

[Monty 4 premiers 08/09]

Don't know how you guys are forgetting Al Mann (NEW)????
Freak

[No Good at cricket]

Originally Posted by Monty 4 premiers 08/09

Don't know how you guys are forgetting Al Mann (NEW)????
Freak

I agree easliy best top order batsmen in Money Shield

[Wattle Glenn 2010]

Originally Posted by No Good at cricket

I agree easliy best top order batsmen in Money Shield

This best 11 would dominate many other A grade rep sides.
1 MarK Minney (EL)
2 Rosebroock (PY)
3 D.Love (PY)
4 W.Glynn (DC)
5 T.Keays (LS)
6 S.Gibbs (RV) Capt
7 E.Smale (RV)
8 B.Zaffera (LP)
9 J.Whiticher (LE)
10 Turner (RH)
11 P.Hurst (EP)

[bigcricket007]

I still don't understand how any of you blokes have left Arnberger out of your best senior XI's. Last I checked, he fitted the criteria:

- is a senior cricketer
- plays D.V.C.A

As good as all our DVCA local legends are... none of them has over 6000 FIRST CLASS runs.



Just a quick question also... what is with the lack of Money Shield blokes nominated? If Shane Warne was playing at a Money Shield club... would he get looked over because he isn't grinding away with the 'big boys' in Barclay?

Just because a club is in a lower grade, doesn't make a talented individual any less of a cricketer... there is some decent talent floating around in Money Shield. Anyway, thats just MY opinion.